zu Headwaters: unten, fett
Energy
Weighing the Alternatives in EnergyBy Richard Suttmeier
5/17/2006 2:03 PM EDT
All the hype about alternative-energy stocks makes me think, here we go again. During the Carter presidency, in the wake of the oil embargo of 1973, the talk was that solar panels, wind and the tides would solve our energy needs.
Did you know that the angular roof of the Citigroup building in Midtown Manhattan was designed to include solar panels to supply its energy needs? Never happened! President Carter wore cardigans in the White House and told Americans to lower their thermostats to reduce fuel use in the winter. He was booted out of office. As soon as oil became plentiful again, the country renewed its overuse of oil.
Today we are running tremendous risks due to the instability of the countries that supply us with crude oil and the fact that 40% of our refinery capacity is in two locations that could be hit by hurricanes in the Gulf of Mexico. Refineries are at full capacity, and I hear only rhetoric that additional capacity will be built. The American response: Not in my backyard.
When crude oil reached $75.35 a barrel on April 21, ethanol plays Archer Daniels Midland (ADM:NYSE) and Pacific Ethanol (PEIX:Nasdaq) renewed momentum runs higher. Earlier this month when crude oil dipped below $70, these stocks took a hit. Other alternative-energy plays peaked out even sooner.
I believe that if the geopolitical risks subside and the hurricane season is benign, Americans will likely forget once again about the need to change our energy policy.
Nymex crude oil is stuck in a random trading range between my semiannual support of $64.58 and my quarterly resistance of $75.94. Higher prices have reduced demand, maintaining a ceiling on prices. However, geopolitical risks have built a floor at much higher levels than in the past. As crude oil trades towards support, the urgency of alternative energy will subside.
Alternative energy and ethanol have been hyped so much recently that most names are overvalued. The industry is 33.6% overvalued, as compared with 13.8% for the overall energy sector. These companies will likely remain overvalued as long as crude oil prices stay high. If you own them, I recommend trading around core holdings by using good-till-canceled limit orders to buy on weakness if they fall to my value levels and sell if they rise to a risky level.
The Ethanol Plays
Archer Daniels Midland, the self-styled supermarket to the world, converts corn to ethyl alcohol, some of which is converted to ethanol. ADM is rated a hold by ValuEngine and is 37.8% overvalued, with fair value at $31.30. The weekly chart profile shows overbought momentum with the five-week modified moving average at $38.38.
ADM has gone parabolic, with no risky levels at which to sell. Investors long this stock should be aware of the risk if the ethanol bubble breaks. Investors should hold on to longs for now, but don't add to positions. Consider protecting long-term gains with a sell stop on a weekly close below the rising five-week MMA.
Pacific Ethanol is a 3-year-old company that is developing facilities to produce cellulose-based ethanol and biodiesel in the western U.S. It is rated a hold by ValuEngine and is 65.7% overvalued, with fair value at $22.87. The weekly chart profile is overbought, with the five-week MMA at $31.76. Investors should reduce holdings if it rises to my monthly pivot, $39.07, and my monthly risky level, $42.82.
Other Alternative-Energy Plays
Evergreen Solar (ESLR:Nasdaq) already peaked at $17.50 on March 15. The weekly chart profile is negative, with the five-week MMA at $12.09. Even though this name is 21.3% overvalued, investors should be prepared to add to positions on weakness to the 200-day SMA, $11.48, and to my monthly value level, $10.53. It held its 200-day on Tuesday.
Headwaters (HW:NYSE) provides technologies and chemical reagents used to convert coal into a liquid fuel. Headwaters shares peaked at $40.15 on April 3 and fell to a low of $31.64 on Tuesday. The company is rated a buy by ValuEngine and is 12.3% undervalued. The weekly chart profile is negative, with the five-week MMA at $34.91. Investors should buy on weakness to my monthly value level, $28.46, or on a weekly close above the five-week MMA of $34.91, which is declining each week.
If you own other alternative-energy stocks, send me the symbol via email, and I'll respond with my current profile.