ew post on Papua New Guinea Mine Watch
§
§
ABC Reporting on Bougainville – biased and inaccurate like always
by ramunickel
Today the ABC published a story - see below - on yesterday’s peace ceremony held between the PM, Peter O’Neill and Autonomous Bougainville Government President, John Momis. It features a number of omissions and inaccuracies that have become something of a habit for the ABC when reporting on Bougainville.
Fail 1: The Bougainville conflict was a ‘civil war’. Last time we looked civil wars were domestic conflicts between multiple internal actors. ABC seem to have forgotten that Australia and Rio Tinto played a large role in this war. Or perhaps they feel the senior level admissions and mountains of documents are not ‘credible’.
Fail 2: The war was over compensation. Oh please, this is not a schoolboy error, try preschool error. The war started when landowners closed a mine because it was polluting their land and waterways – the Panguna Landowner Association’s message was very clear, money can never compensate for the damage the mine did to land, environment and culture. But, of course, the compensation lie needs to be pumped right now, because it means Rio Tinto can reopen the mine, but this time giving a little bit extra to the locals to keep them chipper.
Fail 3: The ABC has been swooning over a recent Australia Security Policy Institute report which warns Bougainville risks falling back into conflict unless more Australian aid is apportioned to the island and the mine reopened. It was given prime time position last year. And here it is mentioned again, and like in 2013 the ABC fail to mention ASPI is funded by Australia’s Department of Defence – slight conflict of interest perhaps. Never.
Fail 4: Bougainville is ‘under-developed’. Walk around the island, you see lush foliage, rich soils, pregnant waterways, people with a diverse diet, a colourful culture, nothing under-developed about that; except for perhaps the Kawerong Valley and the Jaba river which are choked and polluted.
THE ABC 'story'
Papua New Guinea PM Peter O'Neill and Bougainville President John Momis attend reconciliation ceremony
An official reconciliation ceremony has taken place in Port Moresby between PNG's Prime Minister and the President of the Atonomous Government of Bougainville.
Last year a highly public spat over the effectiveness of Bougainville programs funded by national money strained relations.
Amid traditional music and costumes, the leaders of Papua New Guinea and of the Autonomous Government of Bougainville put on a public show of making up.
PNG Prime Minister Peter O'Neill wore strings of traditional Bougainvillean shell money around his neck, as he atoned for the past.
"Yes we have made many mistakes in the past and we will continue to make mistakes in the future," he said.
"But it must not deprive the rights of our people on Bougainville so that they too can be entitled to better services, they too can enjoy the development and growth that the rest of Papua New Guinea's enjoying."
By his side stood John Momis, the president of the Autonomous Government of Bougainville.
"We should not be sidetracked by all kinds of views and statements that are being expressed in the media," he said.
"So, Mr Prime Minister, I think that it is good that we should be here today to confirm our commitment to once again confirm our commitment to the spirit of bi-partisanship.
The two were coming together after a dispute - played out in the media - over how effectively money from the national budget was being spent on Bougainville.
A lot of work has been done to patch things up and the reconciliation was symbolized by an exchange of vegetables and a pig.
History of conflict
Bougainville's recent history has been one of conflict - disputes over the compensation from an Australian-owned copper mine turned into a civil war in the 1990s.
The resource-rich region remains under-developed and the Australian Security Policy Institute recently warned that Bougainville risks returning to conflict.
But this recent political rift, at least, appears to be healing.
The Bougainvilleans gave Peter O'Neill a bow and arrow that he will take to Bougainville next week and publically break, to show the end of hostilities.
Both men say political leadership is key to development, to peace and to the referendum on independence that Bougainville plans to hold between 2015 and 2020.
"It is incumbent on us as leaders to make sure that we work to the full implementation on that peace agreement so that the benefits of that goes to our people - both in our country and of course on Bougainville," Mr O'Neill said.
A similar sentiment came from Bougainville President John Momis.
"In the final anaylsis it is the politicians who should determine the direction, and call upon the bureaucrats to implement the agreement," he said.
When Peter O'Neill travels to Bougainville next week he will be first PNG prime minister to go do so since the civil war ended in 1997.
ramunickel | January 23, 2014 at 9:05 am | Tags: ABC, Australia, Bougainville, Environmental damage, Human rights, Landholders, media, Panguna, Papua New Guinea, Rio Tinto | Categories: Environmental impact, Human rights, Papua New Guinea | URL: wp.me/pMvf7-2Zg