WorldCom Says It Hid Expenses, Inflating Cash Flow $3.8 Billion
June 26, 2002
By SIMON ROMERO and ALEX BERENSON
WorldCom, the nation's second-largest long-distance
carrier, said last night that it had overstated its cash
flow by more than $3.8 billion during the last five
quarters in what appears to be one of the largest cases of
false corporate bookkeeping yet.
The problem, discovered during an internal audit, throws
into doubt the survival of WorldCom and MCI, the
long-distance company it acquired in 1998. The company,
which was already the subject of a federal investigation
into its accounting practices, has been struggling to
refinance $30 billion in debt. Its credit was relegated to
junk-bond status last month, and even before last night's
announcement, the stock price was down more than 94 percent
so far this year.
Some analysts now see a bankruptcy filing as a strong
possibility, which would follow the pattern of Enron,
Global Crossing and other companies laid low by accounting
scandals since last fall. In an effort to avoid that fate,
WorldCom said last night that it would cut 17,000
employees, or one-fifth of its work force. Analysts had
been expecting a job cut of that magnitude for several
weeks.
Instead of the profit of $1.4 billion the company reported
in 2001 and $130 million in this year's first quarter,
WorldCom now says it lost money during those periods,
although it did not say how much.
In disclosing the bookkeeping problem, WorldCom said it had
fired its chief financial officer, Scott D. Sullivan, the
executive widely credited with helping orchestrate the
financial strategy during the mid-to-late 1990's that
enabled WorldCom to rise from a second-tier
telecommunications company to a world giant through a
series of acquisitions that included the $30 billion
purchase of MCI in 1998.
Mr. Sullivan had been the executive closest to Bernard J.
Ebbers, the company's longtime chief executive, who
abruptly resigned in April, owing WorldCom more than $366
million for loans and loan guarantees the company had made
to him.
WorldCom's board said it had fired Mr. Sullivan after
discovering a strategy in which operating costs like basic
network maintenance had been booked as capital investments,
an accounting gimmick that enabled WorldCom to hide
expenses, inflate its cash flow and report profits instead
of losses. Until last month, WorldCom's auditor had been
Arthur Andersen, the accounting firm that also audited the
books of Enron and Global Crossing.
Arthur Andersen issued a statement last night saying that
WorldCom's chief financial officer had not told the firm
about the accounting techniques now being called into
question. "Our work for WorldCom complied with S.E.C. and
professional standards at all times," the statement said.
WorldCom replaced Arthur Andersen with KPMG last month and
said last night that it had asked KPMG to undertake a
comprehensive audit of the company's financial statements
for 2001 and 2002.
"Our senior management team is shocked by these
discoveries," said John W. Sidgmore, who became WorldCom's
chief executive after Mr. Ebbers left in April. "I want to
assure our customers and employees that the company remains
viable and committed to a long-term future."
But it remains to be seen how WorldCom's customers will
react to the disclosure of the massive accounting
irregularities. In addition to providing millions of
consumers with long-distance service through its MCI unit,
WorldCom sells sophisticated data communications services
to many of the world's largest companies.
WorldCom, which had a peak value of $115.3 billion in June
1999 when its shares reached a high of $62, is now worth
less than $1 billion. Its stock, which had already been
down more than 94 percent for the year before last night's
disclosure, plunged as low as 26 cents in after-hours
trading last night.
In addition to dismissing Mr. Sullivan, WorldCom's board
said it had accepted the resignation of David Myers as
senior vice president and financial controller. The company
said it had notified the Securities and Exchange
Commission, which had already been investigating the
company's accounting. WorldCom also said it was hiring
William R. McLucas, the former chief of the enforcement
division of the S.E.C., to conduct an independent
investigation.
Mr. Sullivan was unavailable for comment.
The S.E.C. said in a statement released early today that
the disclosures confirmed "accounting improprieties of
unprecedented magnitude."
The statement, by Christi Harlan, director of public
affairs, said the commission was ordering the company to
file, under oath, "a detailed report of the circumstances
and specifics of these matters."
The agency also said the events "further demonstrate the
need for comprehensive market regulatory reforms that the
administration, the Congress and the S.E.C. have been
advocating and implementing."
The company said last night that it had informed its main
bank lenders of the bookkeeping problems. It is currently
in tense negotiations with its banks, a group led by
Citigroup, Bank of America and J. P. Morgan Chase, about
restructuring lines of credit worth about $5 billion.
Last night's disclosure is expected to add to the problems
of telecommunications companies to arrange financing as the
industry's long slump continues.
"This is horrible for the industry," said Susan Kalla,
senior telecommunications analyst at Friedman, Billings &
Ramsey. "If we can't hang our hat on historical numbers,
why should we believe in the present figures?"
The size of Worldcom's restatement surprised even hardened
short-sellers - investors who profit when stocks fall and
generally view corporate America with skepticism. "I'm kind
of shaken by that," said James Chanos, a short-seller who
played a major role in unearthing Enron's overstated
profits and hidden debt. "I'm about as cynical as they
come. It's pretty amazing."
Particularly disturbing, Mr. Chanos said, is that WorldCom
had manipulated its cash flow statements, not just its
reported earnings. Investors used to believe that cash flow
was a more reliable indicator of a company's financial
health because the number could not be manipulated as
easily as earnings, but that assumption now appears to be
wrong. WorldCom now joins a list that includes Dynegy,
Adelphia Communications and Tyco International as companies
that have apparently used financial gimmicks to inflate
their cash flow.
"The one touchstone that investors had was that you
couldn't fudge cash flow numbers, but apparently you can,"
Mr. Chanos said. "Like any system, it can be gamed if
enough people are looking at something, an unscrupulous
management will find a way to game it."
WorldCom's news rattled investors in other companies. In
after-hours trading, technology and telecom stocks and
broad market indexes plunged after word of the accounting
problem, first reported by the financial news cable network
CNBC. Stocks had already fallen in regular trading
yesterday. The Nasdaq 100 index, composed mainly of big
technology stocks, fell almost 3 percent in after-hours
trading, while the Standard & Poor's 500 index of major
companies dropped more than 1.5 percent.
David Tice, another short-seller, said WorldCom's rise and
fall was emblematic of larger problems in Wall Street and
corporate America.
When WorldCom's stock was rising, Mr. Tice said, investors
cheered its acquisition binge and paid little attention to
how the company generated its profits. That attitude, he
said, encouraged the company to stretch accounting rules
and take ever-bigger risks in an effort to keep its stock
rising.
During the late 1990's, "the executives, the money
managers, the auditors, the C.F.O.'s, the C.E.O.'s, the
ones that got ahead were the most reckless, the least
ethical," Mr. Tice said.
"The most reckless guys were the ones that ended up having
the most power and the highest market valuations," he said.
www.nytimes.com/2002/06/26/technology/...1&en=09f9937634153bda
June 26, 2002
By SIMON ROMERO and ALEX BERENSON
WorldCom, the nation's second-largest long-distance
carrier, said last night that it had overstated its cash
flow by more than $3.8 billion during the last five
quarters in what appears to be one of the largest cases of
false corporate bookkeeping yet.
The problem, discovered during an internal audit, throws
into doubt the survival of WorldCom and MCI, the
long-distance company it acquired in 1998. The company,
which was already the subject of a federal investigation
into its accounting practices, has been struggling to
refinance $30 billion in debt. Its credit was relegated to
junk-bond status last month, and even before last night's
announcement, the stock price was down more than 94 percent
so far this year.
Some analysts now see a bankruptcy filing as a strong
possibility, which would follow the pattern of Enron,
Global Crossing and other companies laid low by accounting
scandals since last fall. In an effort to avoid that fate,
WorldCom said last night that it would cut 17,000
employees, or one-fifth of its work force. Analysts had
been expecting a job cut of that magnitude for several
weeks.
Instead of the profit of $1.4 billion the company reported
in 2001 and $130 million in this year's first quarter,
WorldCom now says it lost money during those periods,
although it did not say how much.
In disclosing the bookkeeping problem, WorldCom said it had
fired its chief financial officer, Scott D. Sullivan, the
executive widely credited with helping orchestrate the
financial strategy during the mid-to-late 1990's that
enabled WorldCom to rise from a second-tier
telecommunications company to a world giant through a
series of acquisitions that included the $30 billion
purchase of MCI in 1998.
Mr. Sullivan had been the executive closest to Bernard J.
Ebbers, the company's longtime chief executive, who
abruptly resigned in April, owing WorldCom more than $366
million for loans and loan guarantees the company had made
to him.
WorldCom's board said it had fired Mr. Sullivan after
discovering a strategy in which operating costs like basic
network maintenance had been booked as capital investments,
an accounting gimmick that enabled WorldCom to hide
expenses, inflate its cash flow and report profits instead
of losses. Until last month, WorldCom's auditor had been
Arthur Andersen, the accounting firm that also audited the
books of Enron and Global Crossing.
Arthur Andersen issued a statement last night saying that
WorldCom's chief financial officer had not told the firm
about the accounting techniques now being called into
question. "Our work for WorldCom complied with S.E.C. and
professional standards at all times," the statement said.
WorldCom replaced Arthur Andersen with KPMG last month and
said last night that it had asked KPMG to undertake a
comprehensive audit of the company's financial statements
for 2001 and 2002.
"Our senior management team is shocked by these
discoveries," said John W. Sidgmore, who became WorldCom's
chief executive after Mr. Ebbers left in April. "I want to
assure our customers and employees that the company remains
viable and committed to a long-term future."
But it remains to be seen how WorldCom's customers will
react to the disclosure of the massive accounting
irregularities. In addition to providing millions of
consumers with long-distance service through its MCI unit,
WorldCom sells sophisticated data communications services
to many of the world's largest companies.
WorldCom, which had a peak value of $115.3 billion in June
1999 when its shares reached a high of $62, is now worth
less than $1 billion. Its stock, which had already been
down more than 94 percent for the year before last night's
disclosure, plunged as low as 26 cents in after-hours
trading last night.
In addition to dismissing Mr. Sullivan, WorldCom's board
said it had accepted the resignation of David Myers as
senior vice president and financial controller. The company
said it had notified the Securities and Exchange
Commission, which had already been investigating the
company's accounting. WorldCom also said it was hiring
William R. McLucas, the former chief of the enforcement
division of the S.E.C., to conduct an independent
investigation.
Mr. Sullivan was unavailable for comment.
The S.E.C. said in a statement released early today that
the disclosures confirmed "accounting improprieties of
unprecedented magnitude."
The statement, by Christi Harlan, director of public
affairs, said the commission was ordering the company to
file, under oath, "a detailed report of the circumstances
and specifics of these matters."
The agency also said the events "further demonstrate the
need for comprehensive market regulatory reforms that the
administration, the Congress and the S.E.C. have been
advocating and implementing."
The company said last night that it had informed its main
bank lenders of the bookkeeping problems. It is currently
in tense negotiations with its banks, a group led by
Citigroup, Bank of America and J. P. Morgan Chase, about
restructuring lines of credit worth about $5 billion.
Last night's disclosure is expected to add to the problems
of telecommunications companies to arrange financing as the
industry's long slump continues.
"This is horrible for the industry," said Susan Kalla,
senior telecommunications analyst at Friedman, Billings &
Ramsey. "If we can't hang our hat on historical numbers,
why should we believe in the present figures?"
The size of Worldcom's restatement surprised even hardened
short-sellers - investors who profit when stocks fall and
generally view corporate America with skepticism. "I'm kind
of shaken by that," said James Chanos, a short-seller who
played a major role in unearthing Enron's overstated
profits and hidden debt. "I'm about as cynical as they
come. It's pretty amazing."
Particularly disturbing, Mr. Chanos said, is that WorldCom
had manipulated its cash flow statements, not just its
reported earnings. Investors used to believe that cash flow
was a more reliable indicator of a company's financial
health because the number could not be manipulated as
easily as earnings, but that assumption now appears to be
wrong. WorldCom now joins a list that includes Dynegy,
Adelphia Communications and Tyco International as companies
that have apparently used financial gimmicks to inflate
their cash flow.
"The one touchstone that investors had was that you
couldn't fudge cash flow numbers, but apparently you can,"
Mr. Chanos said. "Like any system, it can be gamed if
enough people are looking at something, an unscrupulous
management will find a way to game it."
WorldCom's news rattled investors in other companies. In
after-hours trading, technology and telecom stocks and
broad market indexes plunged after word of the accounting
problem, first reported by the financial news cable network
CNBC. Stocks had already fallen in regular trading
yesterday. The Nasdaq 100 index, composed mainly of big
technology stocks, fell almost 3 percent in after-hours
trading, while the Standard & Poor's 500 index of major
companies dropped more than 1.5 percent.
David Tice, another short-seller, said WorldCom's rise and
fall was emblematic of larger problems in Wall Street and
corporate America.
When WorldCom's stock was rising, Mr. Tice said, investors
cheered its acquisition binge and paid little attention to
how the company generated its profits. That attitude, he
said, encouraged the company to stretch accounting rules
and take ever-bigger risks in an effort to keep its stock
rising.
During the late 1990's, "the executives, the money
managers, the auditors, the C.F.O.'s, the C.E.O.'s, the
ones that got ahead were the most reckless, the least
ethical," Mr. Tice said.
"The most reckless guys were the ones that ended up having
the most power and the highest market valuations," he said.
www.nytimes.com/2002/06/26/technology/...1&en=09f9937634153bda