Eine Rakete, die aus einem Laptop hervorgeht als Symbol für Start-up-Ideen (Symbolbild).
Montag, 08.05.2017 16:30 von | Aufrufe: 96

Tenzing Global Urges Brightcove Stockholders to Hold CEO and Board Accountable for Significant Underperformance by Voting Against David Mendels and Derek Harrar at Upcoming Annual Meeting

Eine Rakete, die aus einem Laptop hervorgeht als Symbol für Start-up-Ideen (Symbolbild). © peshkov / iStock / Getty Images Plus / Getty Images

PR Newswire

SAN FRANCISCO, May 8, 2017 /PRNewswire/ -- Tenzing Global Management, LLC ("Tenzing Global"), a significant, long-term stockholder of Brightcove, Inc. (Nasdaq: BCOV) ("Brightcove" or the "Company) with an ownership stake of 4.2% of the shares outstanding, issued a statement today criticizing the Board for its failure to hold CEO David Mendels accountable for the substantial destruction of value that stockholders have suffered for over five years. Tenzing Global calls on fellow stockholders to reject the re-election of two directors to the Brightcove Board of Directors at the upcoming 2017 Annual Meeting of Stockholders by voting to "WITHHOLD ALL" on Proposal 1 (election of directors) on the Company's Proxy Card. 

Tenzing Global reminds stockholders that the 2017 Annual Meeting is just 2 days away. Stockholders must express their disappointment in the CEO and Board by a withhold vote against directors Mendels and Harrar. As recently as March, Tenzing Global's stockholder director had been informed by the CEO that Q1 financial performance was tracking to plan, and had not been informed of any weakness in guidance. Based partially on that assurance, Tenzing Global withdrew its nominated alternative slate of directors. Less than 5 days before the Annual Meeting, stockholders learned the magnitude of the continued poor operating performance of the Company under this CEO.

Even though Brightcove has an archaic, democracy-unfriendly plurality voting standard in place for director elections, where just one vote in favor is enough to elect a director, Tenzing Global believes voter turnout against the 2 incumbent directors at this Wednesday's 2017 Annual Meeting will send a clear message to the Board that immediate changes are required and that stockholders will not tolerate the status quo.

Tenzing Global urges stockholders to reject the following directors by voting to "WITHHOLD ALL" on Proposal 1 on the Company's Proxy Card:

  • David Mendels, Chief Executive Officer of Brightcove
  • Derek Harrar, a director since January 2014

"Tenzing Global has met hundreds of great management teams and boards, with whom we have formed long-standing collaborative relationships that have enabled us to compound our investors' capital at over 13% net of fees since 2013. Brightcove possesses all the components of a successful company: industry-leading products and technologies, a highly recognizable brand, and dedicated employees. At Brightcove, we have been working constructively as long-term stockholders since April 2013, first as an outside stockholder and then as a stockholder director for the last two years," said Chet Kapoor, Portfolio Manager and Managing Partner of Tenzing Global. "Our ideas were met with resistance from a Board that was unwilling to hold the CEO accountable for poor corporate performance. Last week, I was surprised to learn of the sudden weakness at Brightcove subsequent to my resignation from the Board. David Mendels' recent confidence was yet again clearly misplaced. We strongly believe Brightcove can achieve its full potential under a new CEO and a reconstituted Board."

Consistent Poor Execution under David Mendels' Stewardship

The Company delivered extremely disappointing results for its fiscal year 2017 first quarter on May 4, 2017. The Company significantly revised downward its full year guidance at the mid-point for total revenue from $165 million to $153 million, and alarmingly, non-GAAP operating margin from +3% to -5%, and its Non-GAAP earnings per share from +$0.11 to -$0.24. To put those results into a 5-year perspective, the Company presented a target of long-term operating margins of +20% in its 2013 Analyst Day.


ARIVA.DE Börsen-Geflüster

Kurse

1,54
-1,91%
Brightcove Realtime-Chart

Fiscal Year 2017 Guidance ($ in millions, except per share data)

Downward


As given February 16, 2017

As given May 4, 2017

Revision %




Implied



Implied

from

Metrics

Low

High

Mid-point

Low

High

Mid-point

2/16/17 to 5/4/17

Revenue

$ 163.0

$ 167.0

$    165.0

$ 151.0

$ 155.0

$     153.0

-7.3%

Non-GAAP operating income

$     3.5

$     6.0

$        4.8

$   (9.0)

$   (6.0)

$       (7.5)

-257.9%

Non-GAAP operating margin (implied)

2.1%

3.7%

2.9%

-5.8%

-4.0%

-4.9%


Non-GAAP earnings per share

$   0.07

$   0.14

$      0.11

$ (0.28)

$ (0.19)

$     (0.24)

-323.8%

During David Mendels' tenure as CEO, the Company has repeatedly lowered expectations. and reset Wall Street expectations. In addition to the mis-execution this quarter, other serious missteps by the CEO include the overpriced and margin-dilutive acquisition of Unicorn Media in early 2014, the loss of its largest customer Rovio in mid-2014, and the expectation of a greater than 90% reduction of revenue from its largest customer in early 2017. Notably, the CEO has clung to a dual business unit structure that suppresses corporate profitability.

We are not alone in our lack of confidence in the leadership:

Sameet Sinha (B. Riley, 5/5/17)
"With such a downdraft, the stock trades at 1.0x 2018 revenue, but we choose to downgrade after the fact as we call into question management credibility…The sudden reduction of contract values resets prior expectations laid out in Q1 of Q/Q improvement throughout the year. Management spoke about resumption of double digit revenue growth in FY18 after a four quarter digestion period, but we have very little confidence in this."

We are also not alone in seeing opportunities for the Company with a different strategy than that set by leadership:

Tom Roderick (Stifel, 5/4/17)
"We see Brightcove as still the best player in a crowded market, and we further see the potential for external shareholder pressures to push Brightcove into the arms of a strategic or financial buyer, or to push the company toward a more profitable model."

Underperformance of Brightcove's Stock Price

Over the last five years, the Company's stock price return of -65% has significantly underperformed the S&P 500 and the Russell 2000. In addition, since its Initial Public Offering, Brightcove's stock has returned -45% to stockholders.

5-Year Stock Price Performance as of May 5, 2017 (post-fiscal year 2017 first quarter earnings):

  • Brightcove: -65%
  • S&P 500: +75%
  • Russell 2000: +76%

CEO Pay NOT Aligned with Stockholders

Equally troubling, the Board has failed to align CEO compensation with that of the Company's stockholders. The Company's CEO has received nearly $3 million in cash compensation since 2012. The Company's CEO annual total cash compensation and bonus compensation have increased 112% and 226%, respectively, over a 5-year period versus Brightcove's 5-year stock price returns of -65%. Inconsistent with the Company's 5-year stock price performance of -65%, the Board has determined that in four of the last five years, the Company's CEO has achieved over 100% of his annual target. This disconnect raises a red-flag regarding not only pay for performance, but also the absence of true economic alignment with the stockholders and a Board unwilling to hold the CEO accountable.


Cash Compensation (as given by proxy)

Equity Compensation (as given by proxy)




Bonus Compensation









Achievement







Year

Base
Salary

 Bonus Target
% of Base

(As Determined
by Board)

Total Bonus
Compensation

Total Cash
Compensation

Option Awards

Stock Awards

Total Equity
Awards

Total Compensation

2012

$250,000

35%

131.0%

$114,669

$364,669


$903,500

$903,500

$1,268,169

2013

$325,000

50%

150.0%

$243,750

$568,750


$846,029

$846,029

$1,414,779

2014

$325,000

Werbung

Mehr Nachrichten zur Brightcove Aktie kostenlos abonnieren

E-Mail-Adresse
Benachrichtigungen von ARIVA.DE
(Mit der Bestellung akzeptierst du die Datenschutzhinweise)

Hinweis: ARIVA.DE veröffentlicht in dieser Rubrik Analysen, Kolumnen und Nachrichten aus verschiedenen Quellen. Die ARIVA.DE AG ist nicht verantwortlich für Inhalte, die erkennbar von Dritten in den „News“-Bereich dieser Webseite eingestellt worden sind, und macht sich diese nicht zu Eigen. Diese Inhalte sind insbesondere durch eine entsprechende „von“-Kennzeichnung unterhalb der Artikelüberschrift und/oder durch den Link „Um den vollständigen Artikel zu lesen, klicken Sie bitte hier.“ erkennbar; verantwortlich für diese Inhalte ist allein der genannte Dritte.


Andere Nutzer interessierten sich auch für folgende News